🏠 Rating system

Scoring: home savings plan comparison

This is how we rate building societies and home savings plans. A home savings contract combines a savings phase with a loan at a guaranteed rate – so we rate both phases and the fees that arise in between.

Maximum score: 100
Magnifying glass over a house piggy bank Magnifying glass over a house piggy bank
Category Criterion Points breakdown Max. points
Costs Arrangement fee (as % of the contract sum)
  • • No arrangement fee = full points
  • • ≤ 0.5% = 12 points
  • • ≤ 1.0% = 8 points
  • • ≤ 1.6% = 4 points
  • • > 1.6% = 0 points
15
Annual fee / account fee
  • • No ongoing fees = full points
  • • ≤ €12 per year = 4 points
  • • ≤ €24 per year = 2 points
  • • > €24 per year = 0 points
6
Loan fee / premium on allocation
  • • No fee on the home savings loan = full points
  • • ≤ 1% of the loan amount = 2 points
  • • > 1% = 0 points
4
Loan terms APR of the home savings loan
  • • < 2.0% = full points
  • • < 2.5% = 15 points
  • • < 3.0% = 12 points
  • • < 3.5% = 8 points
  • • < 4.5% = 4 points
  • • ≥ 4.5% = 0 points
18
Interest rate security
  • • Loan rate guaranteed from signing = full points
  • • Rate fixed for part of the term only = 2 points
  • • No guaranteed rate = 0 points
5
Repayment / loan term
  • • Low repayment, long term selectable = full points
  • • Standard market repayment = 3 points
  • • High repayment, short term = 0 points
5
Savings phase Interest during the savings phase
  • • ≥ 1.0% p.a. = full points
  • • ≥ 0.5% = 7 points
  • • ≥ 0.25% = 4 points
  • • ≥ 0.1% = 2 points
  • • < 0.1% = 0 points
10
Minimum savings balance for allocation
  • • ≤ 40% of the contract sum = full points
  • • ≤ 50% = 2 points
  • • > 50% = 0 points
4
Regular savings contribution
  • • Freely selectable or ≤ 3‰ of the contract sum = full points
  • • ≤ 5 ‰ = 2 points
  • • > 5‰ = 0 points
3
Allocation & flexibility Transparency of allocation (rating figure, waiting time)
  • • Rating figure and allocation time publicly documented = full points
  • • Only partly documented = 2 points
  • • No public information = 0 points
5
Free special repayments on the home savings loan
  • • Unlimited and free at any time = full points
  • • Limited or only on fixed dates = 3 points
  • • Not possible or charged = 0 points
6
Adjusting the contract sum (increase, reduction, split)
  • • All three variants possible = full points
  • • Partly possible = 2 points
  • • Not possible = 0 points
4
Plan change possible
  • • Switching to other plan variants possible = full points
  • • Restricted only = 1 point
  • • Not possible = 0 points
3
State subsidies Housing construction bonus
  • • Plan eligible for state bonus = full points
  • • Not eligible for state bonus = 0 points
3
Employer savings contributions / employee savings allowance
  • • Eligible for employer savings and state allowance = full points
  • • Employer savings only = 1 point
  • • Not possible = 0 points
2
Wohn-Riester (home ownership pension)
  • • Riester-certified plan available = full points
  • • Not available = 0 points
2
Security & service Deposit protection & supervision
  • • BaFin supervision and statutory deposit protection = full points
  • • Only one of the two safeguards verifiable = 1 point
2
Online management / customer portal
  • • Full online management incl. app = full points
  • • Web portal only = 1 point
  • • No online management = 0 points
2
Phone advice
  • • Reachable hotline = full points
  • • Contact form only = 0 points
1
Total points: 100